Every franchisor claims to believe in ethical franchising. But how many are prepared to put those principles ahead of their immediate commercial interests?
It is easy to talk about integrity, transparency and partnership when franchisees are performing well, royalties are being paid and the network is growing. The real test comes when franchisees are struggling, challenge decisions or want to leave.
Having worked with franchisors and franchisees for many years, I have seen how quickly the language of partnership can disappear when commercial interests diverge.
A contractual right is not a moral justification
Franchise agreements are necessarily weighted in favour of franchisors. They need to protect their brands, intellectual property and the integrity of their networks. But there is a difference between protecting a brand and exploiting a contractual advantage.
A franchisor may have grounds to terminate a franchisee who has fallen behind with royalties but if the business remains viable and the franchisee is willing to engage, is termination necessarily the best outcome?
Similarly, an agreement may allow a franchisor to impose additional costs or operational changes. That does not automatically make those decisions reasonable, particularly where their financial impact on franchisees has not been properly considered.
Ethical franchising does not mean tolerating persistent breaches or subsidising failing businesses indefinitely. It means exercising contractual rights proportionately, with sound commercial judgement.
Stop selling the dream without explaining the reality
Franchise recruitment is another area where ethical principles deserve closer scrutiny.
We regularly hear about exciting opportunities, established business models and the benefits of becoming your own boss. There is often considerably less enthusiasm for discussing the risks.
Financial projections should be realistic and properly substantiated. Prospective franchisees should understand the total investment required, including working capital, and have opportunities to speak openly with existing franchisees.
Of course, franchisees must undertake proper due diligence and accept responsibility for their decisions but franchisors also have responsibilities.
A franchise sale is not a success if the franchisee was never realistically equipped to succeed.
When partnership becomes a one-way street
Franchisors frequently describe franchisees as business partners, yet some relationships operate more like a dictatorship.
Franchisees are expected to follow the system, meet performance targets and implement changes. Those obligations are entirely legitimate.
But what happens when franchisees raise concerns about inadequate support, declining profitability or decisions made by the franchisor? Are those concerns genuinely considered, or is the response simply to point to the franchise agreement or label someone “difficult”?
A franchisor cannot reasonably demand loyalty, transparency and accountability from franchisees while failing to demonstrate those same qualities itself.
What are franchisees actually paying for?
One area where the difference between contractual entitlement and ethical conduct becomes particularly apparent is franchise resales.
Most franchisors charge fees when franchisees sell their businesses and for outgoing and incoming franchisees to be required to cover the franchisor’s legal costs.
This is absolutely right. Resales require appropriate checks, documentation and coordination. Some franchisors handle this exceptionally well, with robust processes, meaningful support and legal documentation properly tailored to the transaction. Some, however, treat resales as an opportunity to generate additional income.
But are the fees charged always proportionate to the work involved?
For example, where an incoming buyer is already an existing franchisee, much of the usual recruitment, assessment and onboarding process may be unnecessary. Similarly, where the parties’ own solicitors have prepared the sale documentation, the franchisor’s legal involvement may be considerably reduced.
In those circumstances, shouldn’t franchisors be prepared to review and, where appropriate, reduce their fees to reflect the work actually undertaken?
This is not about expecting franchisors to provide services for free or suggesting that every resale should attract the same charges. Quite the opposite. Fees should reflect the nature and complexity of the particular transaction, rather than automatically applying a standard charge regardless of the circumstances.
The fact that a franchise agreement permits a fee does not automatically make it reasonable or commercially justified.
Franchisors are entitled to protect their networks and recover legitimate costs. But a resale should not become an opportunity to generate additional revenue simply because a franchisee has little practical alternative but to pay.
How a franchisor treats someone leaving its network can reveal just as much about its commitment to ethical franchising as how it welcomes someone joining it.
Growth is not the same as success
We celebrate expanding networks, increasing franchisee numbers and territories sold. But how many franchisees are profitable? How many have left? How many would invest in the same franchise again?
Perhaps these are the figures we should be celebrating, rather than the number of agreements signed.
Ethics are demonstrated, not declared
Ethical franchising does not mean always agreeing with franchisees or avoiding commercially difficult decisions. It means acting consistently, being transparent and exercising contractual rights responsibly.
The franchise sector rightly promotes the benefits of its business model. We should be equally willing to challenge practices that undermine confidence in it.
Ultimately, ethical franchising is not about what a franchisor says when things are going well.
It is about what it does when doing the right thing costs money, requires compromise or means relinquishing an advantage it could otherwise exploit.
That is where ethical franchising really begins.
This article comes courtesy of Excello Law, a national law firm advising franchisors and franchisees on all aspects of franchising.







