I’ve never had a chance to go on ‘Deal or no Deal’, but I’d do it just to meet the bearded legend that is Noel Edmonds. Mainly because I want to know the truth about Mr Blobby, and what really was in that gunge tank on Noel’s House Party.
The chance of winning £250,000 would also add a nice sweetener. After all, you have a 1 in 22 chance – 4.5% if you are interested – of picking the right box and swanning off with a big bag of cash PLUS the gossip from Crinkly Bottom.
However, for those of you old enough to remember, I’d rather have met Monty Hall. Not because he had a questionable monosyllabic pink sidekick, but because he is the namesake of my favourite example of why not being afraid to change is not only important, but mathematically sensible.
Let me introduce you to the Monty Hall Problem.
On ‘Let’s Make a Deal’ contestants were given a choice of three doors to pick from. Behind two of these doors was a goat, and behind the third was a brand-new car.
You pick a door (let’s say Door #1), and at this stage you have a 33% chance of being right.
Monty Hall—who crucially knows what is behind every door—opens one of the remaining doors (let’s say Door #3) to reveal a goat.
Finally, Monty turns to you and says, ‘Do you want to stick with Door #1, or switch to Door #2?’
Well, you think. It’s 50/50 either way, right? It makes no difference if I stick or twist.
Surprisingly, you’re wrong. Taking the trade doubles your odds of winning, from 33% to 66%. If you don’t believe me, look it up; I promise you that it’s mathematically possible to improve your success rate by making the switch with no further information.
Using mathematical odds of success like this to improve your situation is often overlooked from a business perspective. Yes, there are no guarantees in business (or life, come to think of it) but there are statistically more likely outcomes – let’s look at the stats:
Official BFA survey data shows that 99.5% of franchised units in the UK operate successfully without commercial failure on an annual basis. Over a 20-year span, cumulative commercial failure in franchising stays under 6%. That is a staggeringly low failure rate.
By sharp contrast, government and Experian data reveal that roughly 50% of all independent UK start-up businesses fail within their first three years.
Neither of these statistics guarantees your success or failure. You may start a franchise, and it may fail in year one. Equally, you may start a standalone business and it’s a roaring success after 50 years.
However, using some simple statistical analysis tells us these are the least likely outcomes from your choices.
This is of course before we weave in the comparison to traditional employment. An employee effectively runs a business with one customer: their employer. That single customer provides 100% of their revenue and if that ‘customer’ restructures, cuts budgets, gets acquired, or goes into liquidation, the employee’s income can disappear overnight. Yes, there are safety mechanisms for employees from a legal perspective, but ultimately, it is a binary, high-impact risk hidden behind a steady monthly payslip.
Being self-employed, however, diversifies this risk. A business owner or franchisee typically services 20, 50, or hundreds of clients. If three clients walk away or cut their spending on a Tuesday, it’s an operational headache, not an existential threat. The revenue stream is diversified, and the franchisee’s income (to a certain extent) is protected.
So, what is the takeaway here?
Well, firstly there are no ‘right choices’, only ‘choices’. We cannot know what the future holds for us, but we can use statistical probability to help guide us.
Is franchising right for you? I’ve no idea.
Is it statistically more likely to succeed than a standalone business? Yes, absolutely.
So don’t bother picking up the phone to the banker; the stats are already telling you what you need to know.
Key takeaways
- Switching doors in the Monty Hall problem raises the chance of winning from 33% to 66%.
- Franchised units have a low reported annual commercial failure rate, according to BFA survey data.
- Roughly half of independent UK start-ups fail within their first three years, according to government and Experian data.
- Employment concentrates income risk in one customer: the employer.
- Self-employment can diversify income across multiple clients, making the loss of a few less likely to become an existential threat.









